Cole Shelton

MMA writer and RotoWire betting columnist

Cole Shelton is a full-time sports writer focused on MMA. He writes RotoWire’s MMA Best Bets column. His work has appeared at the BJPenn website, CBC Sports, Sports Betting Dime and Blue Jays Nation.

Scorecard

Called 49 of 88 resolved picks — every call traced to its source, no bare percentage. How Track Record works.

  • Winner Accuracy 55.7% 49 39
  • Method Accuracy 66.7% 2 1
  • Round AccuracyCalls the winner, not the round
  • Underdog Accuracy 21.4% 3 11

Hit Miss

The running record

Every figure below is cumulative — computed over all resolved calls up to and including each card, never one card on its own. A cumulative rate settles as the denominator grows: read where a line sits alongside its denominator. Winner covers every resolved call; method, round and underdog each have a different and much smaller base, printed beside each one.

Hit Miss Field median Gap to the field

Winnerof resolved calls

49 of 88 — 56% now, from 40% at their first scored card.

The opening points are drawn dashed and hollow: below 5 scored calls this rate is not yet a reliable figure.

Round — No round calls

Card by card

Newest card first. One mark per resolved call, hits above the line and misses below. Every call is listed in Call History, below.

  1. UFC 332 4 hit · 1 miss
  2. Rosas Jr. vs. Barcelos 7 hit · 5 miss
  3. Crypto.com UFC 331 5 hit · 7 miss
  4. UFC Freedom 250 5 hit · 2 miss
  5. UFC 328 2 hit · 3 miss
  6. UFC 327 2 hit · 3 miss
  7. UFC 326 2 hit · 3 miss
  8. UFC 325 5 hit · 0 miss
  9. UFC 324 2 hit · 1 miss
  10. UFC 323 2 hit · 2 miss
  11. UFC 322 2 hit · 3 miss
  12. UFC 321 3 hit · 1 miss
  13. UFC 320 3 hit · 2 miss
  14. UFC 319 2 hit · 3 miss
  15. UFC 318 1 hit · 0 miss
  16. UFC 317 2 hit · 3 miss

Call History

Every logged call, grouped by event, scored on Winner, Method, and Round — nothing about a result ever sits behind a click.

underdog pick   favourite pick — shown only for picks with a known pre-fight price. The percentage is the chance the market gave the fighter this analyst picked. Open a row for the price’s source and the credit it earned.

Allen vs. Duncan

Oct 10, 2026 · Meta APEX, Las Vegas, Nevada

Analyst prediction scorecards
FightPickActualWinnerMethodRound
Allen vs DuncanAllen · SubUpcomingAllenSubNot called
Frye Jr. vs HarrisHarris · KO/TKOUpcomingHarrisKO/TKONot called
Godinez vs SouzaGodinez · DecUpcomingGodinezDecNot called
Walker vs MeerschaertMeerschaert · to winUpcomingMeerschaertNot calledNot called
Camilo vs HerbertCamilo · to winUpcomingCamiloNot calledNot called

UFC 332

Silva vs. Wang

Oct 3, 2026 · the Delta Center, Salt Lake City, Utah

Event scorecard

  • Winner Accuracy 80.0% 4 1
  • Method Accuracy 66.7% 2 1
  • Round AccuracyCalls the winner, not the round
  • Underdog AccuracyNo underdog calls with a known pre-fight price
Analyst prediction scorecards
FightPickActualWinnerMethodRound
Ribovics · KO/TKORibovics · KO/TKO R1HitHitNot called
Rodriguez · to winRodriguez · KO/TKO R1HitNot calledNot called
Silva · DecSilva · Dec R5HitHitNot called
Parkin · DecWalker · KO/TKO R1MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Soldic · KO/TKOSoldic · Dec R3HitMissNot called

Rosas Jr. vs. Barcelos

Sep 26, 2026 · Meta APEX, Las Vegas, Nevada

Event scorecard

  • Winner Accuracy 58.3% 7 5
  • Method AccuracyCalls the winner, not the method
  • Round AccuracyCalls the winner, not the round
  • Underdog Accuracy 0.0% 1
Analyst prediction scorecards
FightPickActualWinnerMethodRound
Favourite call, market price 59.7%. Perez · to winPerez · Dec R3HitNot calledNot called
Underdog call, market price 43.3%. Barcelos · to winRosas Jr. · KO/TKO R5MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Jackson · to winJackson · KO/TKO R2HitNot calledNot called
Castaneda · to winHeili · Dec R3MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Favourite call, market price 63.7%. Machado · to winMachado · KO/TKO R2HitNot calledNot called
Bellato · to winEdwards · KO/TKO R3MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Jauregui · to winJauregui · KO/TKO R1HitNot calledNot called
Brener · to winBrener · KO/TKO R1HitNot calledNot called
Favourite call, market price 67.5%. Hernandez · to winHernandez · Sub R1HitNot calledNot called
Nakamura · to winHiestand · Sub R2MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Favourite call, market price 72.7%. Osmanli · to winAkylbek Uulu · DQ R1MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Vieira · to winVieira · Dec R3HitNot calledNot called

Crypto.com UFC 331

Van vs. Pantoja 2

Sep 19, 2026 · Crypto.com Arena, Los Angeles, California

Event scorecard

  • Winner Accuracy 41.7% 5 7
  • Method AccuracyCalls the winner, not the method
  • Round AccuracyCalls the winner, not the round
  • Underdog Accuracy 0.0% 2
Analyst prediction scorecards
FightPickActualWinnerMethodRound
Underdog call, market price 41.5%. Pantoja · to winVan · Dec R5MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Favourite call, market price 72.8%. Tsarukyan · to winTsarukyan · KO/TKO R1HitNot calledNot called
Favourite call, market price 69.9%. Choi · to winPitbull · KO/TKO R1MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Favourite call, market price 91.5%. Steveson · to winSharaf · KO/TKO R1MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Favourite call, market price 70.5%. Baraniewski · to winMenifield · Dec R3MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Favourite call, market price 78.5%. Brito · to winBrito · KO/TKO R1HitNot calledNot called
Favourite call, market price 67.5%. O'Neill · to winO'Neill · Sub R1HitNot calledNot called
Underdog call, market price 37.5%. Ferreira · to winShahbazyan · Dec R3MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Favourite call, market price 81.5%. Gandra · to winGandra · KO/TKO R1HitNot calledNot called
Favourite call, market price 61.5%. Yoo · to winAswell Jr. · Dec R3MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Favourite call, market price 79.5%. Despaigne · to winDespaigne · Dec R3HitNot calledNot called
Favourite call, market price 64.5%. Jourdain · to winVera · KO/TKO R3MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed

UFC Freedom 250

Topuria vs. Gaethje

Jun 14, 2026 · Washington, D.C.

Event scorecard

  • Winner Accuracy 71.4% 5 2
  • Method AccuracyCalls the winner, not the method
  • Round AccuracyCalls the winner, not the round
  • Underdog Accuracy 50.0% 1 1
Analyst prediction scorecards
FightPickActualWinnerMethodRound
Favourite call, market price 79.5%. Topuria · to winGaethje · KO/TKO R4MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Underdog call, market price 47.5%. Gane · to winGane · KO/TKO R2HitNot calledNot called
Favourite call, market price 77.5%. O'Malley · to winO'Malley · KO/TKO R2HitNot calledNot called
Favourite call, market price 79.5%. Hokit · to winHokit · KO/TKO R2HitNot calledNot called
Favourite call, market price 81.0%. Ruffy · to winRuffy · KO/TKO R1HitNot calledNot called
Favourite call, market price 75.5%. Nickal · to winNickal · KO/TKO R1HitNot calledNot called
Underdog call, market price 40.5%. Garcia · to winLopes · KO/TKO R2MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed

UFC 328

May 9, 2026 · Newark, New Jersey

Event scorecard

  • Winner Accuracy 40.0% 2 3
  • Method AccuracyCalls the winner, not the method
  • Round AccuracyCalls the winner, not the round
  • Underdog Accuracy 50.0% 1 1
Analyst prediction scorecards
FightPickActualWinnerMethodRound
Favourite call, market price 80.5%. Chimaev · to winStrickland · Dec R5MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Favourite call, market price 60.5%. Taira · to winVan · KO/TKO R5MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Underdog call, market price 43.5%. Cortes-Acosta · to winVolkov · Dec R3MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Underdog call, market price 37.5%. Brady · to winBrady · Dec R3HitNot calledNot called
Favourite call, market price 79.5%. Green · to winGreen · Sub R1HitNot calledNot called

UFC 327

Apr 11, 2026 · Miami, Florida

Event scorecard

  • Winner Accuracy 40.0% 2 3
  • Method AccuracyCalls the winner, not the method
  • Round AccuracyCalls the winner, not the round
  • Underdog Accuracy 0.0% 2
Analyst prediction scorecards
FightPickActualWinnerMethodRound
Underdog call, market price 49.5%. Prochazka · to winUlberg · KO/TKO R1MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Favourite call, market price 68.0%. Murzakanov · to winCosta · KO/TKO R3MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Underdog call, market price 48.5%. Blaydes · to winHokit · Dec R3MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Favourite call, market price 60.5%. Reyes · to winReyes · Dec R3HitNot calledNot called
Favourite call, market price 53.0%. Swanson · to winSwanson · KO/TKO R1HitNot calledNot called

UFC 326

Holloway vs Oliveira 2

Mar 7, 2026 · T-Mobile Arena, Las Vegas, NV, United States

Event scorecard

  • Winner Accuracy 40.0% 2 3
  • Method AccuracyCalls the winner, not the method
  • Round AccuracyCalls the winner, not the round
  • Underdog Accuracy 0.0% 2
Analyst prediction scorecards
FightPickActualWinnerMethodRound
Favourite call, market price 64.5%. Holloway · to winOliveira · Decision - Unanimous R5MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Favourite call, market price 66.5%. Borralho · to winBorralho · Decision - Unanimous R3HitNot calledNot called
Underdog call, market price 26.5%. Font · to winRosas Jr. · Decision - Unanimous R3MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Underdog call, market price 32.5%. Johnson · to winDober · KO/TKO R2MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Favourite call, market price 59.5%. Rodrigues · to winRodrigues · KO/TKO R1HitNot calledNot called

UFC 325

Volkanovski vs Lopes 2

Jan 31, 2026 · Qudos Bank Arena, Sydney Olympic Park, NSW, Australia

Event scorecard

  • Winner Accuracy 100.0% 5
  • Method AccuracyCalls the winner, not the method
  • Round AccuracyCalls the winner, not the round
  • Underdog Accuracy 100.0% 1
Analyst prediction scorecards
FightPickActualWinnerMethodRound
Favourite call, market price 59.5%. Volkanovski · to winVolkanovski · Decision - Unanimous R5HitNot calledNot called
Favourite call, market price 76.5%. Saint Denis · to winSaint Denis · KO/TKO R2HitNot calledNot called
Underdog call, market price 46.5%. Ruffy · to winRuffy · KO/TKO R2HitNot calledNot called
Favourite call, market price 73.5%. Teixeira · to winTeixeira · Decision - Unanimous R3HitNot calledNot called
Favourite call, market price 88.5%. Salkilld · to winSalkilld · Sub R1HitNot calledNot called

UFC 324

Gaethje vs. Pimblett

Jan 24, 2026 · T-Mobile Arena, Las Vegas, Nevada

Event scorecard

  • Winner Accuracy 66.7% 2 1
  • Method AccuracyCalls the winner, not the method
  • Round AccuracyCalls the winner, not the round
  • Underdog AccuracyNo underdog calls with a known pre-fight price
Analyst prediction scorecards
FightPickActualWinnerMethodRound
Favourite call, market price 67.5%. Pimblett · to winGaethje · Decision - Unanimous R5MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Favourite call, market price 65.5%. O'Malley · to winO'Malley · Decision (unanimous) R3HitNot calledNot called
Favourite call, market price 65.5%. Silva · to winSilva · Decision - Unanimous R3HitNot calledNot called

UFC 323

Dvalishvili vs Yan 2

Dec 6, 2025 · T-Mobile Arena, Las Vegas, NV, United States

Event scorecard

  • Winner Accuracy 50.0% 2 2
  • Method AccuracyCalls the winner, not the method
  • Round AccuracyCalls the winner, not the round
  • Underdog AccuracyNo underdog calls with a known pre-fight price
Analyst prediction scorecards
FightPickActualWinnerMethodRound
Favourite call, market price 77.5%. Dvalishvili · to winYan · Decision - Unanimous R5MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Favourite call, market price 66.5%. Pantoja · to winVan · KO/TKO R1MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Favourite call, market price 53.5%. Taira · to winTaira · KO/TKO R2HitNot calledNot called
Favourite call, market price 68.5%. Talbott · to winTalbott · Decision - Unanimous R3HitNot calledNot called
Guskov vs BłachowiczBłachowicz · to winDecision - MajorityBłachowiczNot calledNot called

UFC 322

Della Maddalena vs Makhachev

Nov 15, 2025 · Madison Square Garden, New York, NY, United States

Event scorecard

  • Winner Accuracy 40.0% 2 3
  • Method AccuracyCalls the winner, not the method
  • Round AccuracyCalls the winner, not the round
  • Underdog Accuracy 0.0% 2
Analyst prediction scorecards
FightPickActualWinnerMethodRound
Underdog call, market price 26.5%. Della Maddalena · to winMakhachev · Decision - Unanimous R5MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Favourite call, market price 57.5%. Shevchenko · to winShevchenko · Decision - Unanimous R5HitNot calledNot called
Favourite call, market price 56.5%. Brady · to winMorales · KO/TKO R1MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Favourite call, market price 59.0%. Prates · to winPrates · KO/TKO R2HitNot calledNot called
Underdog call, market price 36.0%. Dariush · to winSaint Denis · KO/TKO R1MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed

UFC 321

Aspinall vs Gane

Oct 25, 2025 · Etihad Arena, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates

Event scorecard

  • Winner Accuracy 75.0% 3 1
  • Method AccuracyCalls the winner, not the method
  • Round AccuracyCalls the winner, not the round
  • Underdog AccuracyNo underdog calls with a known pre-fight price
Analyst prediction scorecards
FightPickActualWinnerMethodRound
Aspinall vs GaneAspinall · to winNo Contest - Accidental Eye PokeAspinallNot calledNot called
Dern · to winDern · Decision - Unanimous R5HitNot calledNot called
Nurmagomedov · to winNurmagomedov · Decision - Unanimous R3HitNot calledNot called
Almeida · to winVolkov · Decision - Split R3MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Murzakanov · to winMurzakanov · KO/TKO R1HitNot calledNot called

UFC 320

Oct 4, 2025 · Las Vegas, Nevada

Event scorecard

  • Winner Accuracy 60.0% 3 2
  • Method AccuracyCalls the winner, not the method
  • Round AccuracyCalls the winner, not the round
  • Underdog AccuracyNo underdog calls with a known pre-fight price
Analyst prediction scorecards
FightPickActualWinnerMethodRound
Ankalaev · to winPereira · KO/TKO R1MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Dvalishvili · to winDvalishvili · Dec R5HitNot calledNot called
Prochazka · to winProchazka · KO/TKO R3HitNot calledNot called
Zalal · to winZalal · Sub R1HitNot calledNot called
Magomedov · to winPyfer · Sub R2MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed

UFC 319

Du Plessis vs Chimaev

Aug 16, 2025 · United Center, Chicago, IL, United States

Event scorecard

  • Winner Accuracy 40.0% 2 3
  • Method AccuracyCalls the winner, not the method
  • Round AccuracyCalls the winner, not the round
  • Underdog AccuracyNo underdog calls with a known pre-fight price
Analyst prediction scorecards
FightPickActualWinnerMethodRound
Du Plessis · to winChimaev · Decision - Unanimous R5MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Murphy · to winMurphy · KO/TKO R1HitNot calledNot called
Prates · to winPrates · KO/TKO R1HitNot calledNot called
Cannonier · to winPage · Decision - Unanimous R3MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Asakura · to winElliott · Sub R2MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed

UFC 318

Holloway vs. Poirier 3

Jul 19, 2025 · Smoothie King Center, New Orleans, Louisiana

Event scorecard

  • Winner Accuracy 100.0% 1
  • Method AccuracyCalls the winner, not the method
  • Round AccuracyCalls the winner, not the round
  • Underdog AccuracyNo underdog calls with a known pre-fight price
Analyst prediction scorecards
FightPickActualWinnerMethodRound
Holloway · to winHolloway · Decision (unanimous) R5HitNot calledNot called

UFC 317

Jun 28, 2025 · Las Vegas, Nevada

Event scorecard

  • Winner Accuracy 40.0% 2 3
  • Method AccuracyCalls the winner, not the method
  • Round AccuracyCalls the winner, not the round
  • Underdog AccuracyNo underdog calls with a known pre-fight price
Analyst prediction scorecards
FightPickActualWinnerMethodRound
Topuria · to winTopuria · KO R1HitNot calledNot called
Pantoja · to winPantoja · Sub R3HitNot calledNot called
Royval · to winVan · Dec R3MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Moicano · to winDariush · Dec R3MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed
Lima · to winTalbott · Dec R3MissNot applicable — the winner call missedNot applicable — the winner call missed

Videos

No sourced clips are linked to this analyst's calls yet.

Watch all of Cole Shelton's video picks in the library